
In summary
Medical negligence claims may be available when a health professional or hospital fails to provide an appropriate standard of care and causes harm. A poor outcome alone is not enough, because complications can happen even absent negligence.
A claim generally requires proof of a duty of care, a breach of that duty supported by an independent expert, a causative link between the breach of duty and the injury and compensable loss.
Losses may include medical expenses, lost income, superannuation and future care costs.
Medical negligence may involve misdiagnosis, surgical or anaesthetic errors, or failures by health services.
Claims may be made against practitioners, hospitals or health services. Defective products may instead involve a manufacturer.
You may be able to make a medical negligence claim if a health professional or hospital failed to provide the right standard of care and this caused you harm. A poor outcome doesn’t automatically mean something went wrong. Many complications are known risks of treatment. Here’s what you need to know about making a medical negligence claim in Australia.
What is medical negligence?
Perhaps the best way of defining medical negligence to someone who may be considering making a claim is to describe the legal test, or process, used in these cases (a legal test is a standard way of evaluating a legal case to ensure there is consistency and fairness across cases).
To prove medical negligence, you and your legal team must be able to demonstrate that:
A health professional or institution (your doctor or your hospital, for example) owed you a duty of care.
To prove that a breach of duty took place, you need to show that the medical professional or hospital acted in a manner that would be considered outside reasonable practice. You need an independent expert to prove this breach. As your lawyer, we would contact such an expert on your behalf, determine whether they support your claim and then ask them specific questions about your case.
In addition to showing that the doctor or hospital breached their duty of care, you need to establish that this breach caused, or materially contributed to, an injury. This is where things can become a little bit complex. For one, it can be difficult to obtain evidence relating to certain injuries or diseases.
Once a breach of the duty of care has been proven to have caused your injury, the question of what you can claim for arises. Different states have quite stringent tests associated with qualifying for pain and suffering damages. In addition to pain and suffering, you may be able to seek compensation for medical expenses, loss of wages and future wages, loss of superannuation and future superannuation, and your future care costs.
What the data says: medical complaints
This data comes from the latest Aphra Annual Report. Ahpra notifications are complaints to a regulator. They are not negligence claims. It’s just an indicator of how often patients have reported on their negative experiences in the medical space.
Statistic: Figure
- Total number of complaints: 22, 658
- Complaints received for medical practitioners: 5,217
- Criminal complaints received: 474 (13% lower than previous year)
- Number of complaints received for clinical care: 9,166
- Percentage of practitioners who lost their license after a complaint: 1.4%.
Do you have a medical complaint or claim?
A complaint to Ahpra (or your state health complaints body) can lead to a practitioner being investigated, counselled or restricted. It does not pay you compensation.
A claim seeks compensation for your losses. You can make a claim and if you are eligible, you may want to pursue a medical negligence claim.
What does medical negligence cover?
Medical negligence covers a very broad range of specific errors and issues, from surgical and anaesthetic mistakes to misdiagnosis.
If you’ve suffered because of a defective prosthesis or medical product, you may need to pursue the manufacturer of the product rather than the healthcare provider. This is different from medical negligence, but a medical negligence lawyer can help you determine where the legal line is drawn and who can help you with your case.
It is also important to note that there is an important difference between a medical negligence claim and an unsatisfactory experience. A doctor simply being abrupt almost certainly doesn’t qualify as medical negligence.
Who can I make a claim against?
Medical negligence claims can be brought against healthcare professionals including GPs, specialists, surgeons, dentists, nurses and allied health professionals such as physiotherapists and podiatrists. Many practitioners are covered by the hospital or clinic that employs them, so the claim is often against the health service rather than the individual.
Yes. A hospital can be responsible for the negligence of the doctors and nurses it employs, and for its own failures, such as unsafe staffing, poor handover or unsafe systems. Public hospital claims are often made against the state or local health service. You still have to show a breach of the standard of care and that it caused you tangible harm.
Yes, but a wrong diagnosis is not automatically negligent. Medicine is complex and many conditions look alike. A claim needs two things: a competent doctor would not have made the same decision, and the error or delay made your outcome worse.
Yes, if the surgery fell below a competent standard and caused you harm. A complication alone is not enough. Separate grounds can include operating on the wrong site, retained instruments, or not warning you of a material risk.
In NSW and Victoria, the general rule is 3 years from when you knew, or ought to have known, you had a claim, and no later than 12 years from the act or omission. Courts have considered "discoverability" to turn on when you knew the injury was linked to someone's fault, which in some cases is when you received a medical opinion. Queensland, Western Australia, the ACT and other states have different rules, and exceptions and extensions exist. Get advice early, because delay makes records and evidence harder to obtain.
How we can help
Our team of lawyers can assess and guide you through your medical negligence claim. We handle the complexities of the process, review your medical records and timeline, and arrange independent medical experts to examine your issues. We work out what you may be able to claim for. Depending on your state, that can include pain and suffering, medical expenses, lost income and super, and future care costs. We also explain time limits, which differ by state, so you don't lose your right to claim by waiting. We explain each step in plain language and tell you the likely costs up front. We offer a No Win No Fee arrangement which means you won’t be charged legal fees if your claim is unsuccessful. You may still be liable for third party costs and disbursements.
Add Slater and Gordon as a preferred source on Google, so you can find trusted legal information from experienced lawyers - not just AI-generated answers.
The contents of this blog post are considered accurate as at the date of publication. However the applicable laws may be subject to change, thereby affecting the accuracy of the article. The information contained in this blog post is of a general nature only and is not specific to anyone’s personal circumstances. Please seek legal advice before acting on any of the information contained in this post.