You web browser may not be properly supported. To use this site and all its features we recommend using the latest versions of Chrome, Safari or Firefox


Switching insurers can be risky business. Make sure you know what's involved before you change policies.

The federal government’s planned changes to financial advice laws (FOFA) has focussed attention on the big banks’ practice of promoting their own products – including insurance – to people who don’t need them or would be better off without them.

Adele Ferguson’s article in the Sydney Morning Herald tells the story of a man, Noel Stevens, who had life insurance, but was convinced by his bank’s financial planning arm to switch over to their insurer (all of the big banks have insurers). When Mr Stevens was diagnosed with terminal cancer, and made a claim, the insurer refused to pay. He took the case to Court, and won three days before he died.

Mr Steven’s sad story highlights the risks of switching insurers (such as life or disability to another).

There are two main types of risks when switching insurers

The first risk is that some insurance policies have exclusions for pre-existing conditions, or do not pay out until a waiting period has passed. What this means is, if you had a condition before you switched insurance policies, and that condition came back after you switched, you risk not being paid by your new insurer because the policy does not pay out for pre-existing conditions.

You might be able to fight the insurer in Court, but the reality is you would never have had this problem if you did not switch insurers.

The second risk of switching insurers is that the new insurer might try to cancel an insurance policy on the grounds that a person did not tell them something from their medical history. An insurer may allege ‘non-disclosure’ for example, if you had a history of mental illness but developed a condition that wasn’t related. The insurer might try to allege that because you didn’t tell them about your medical history, they don’t have to pay for the current condition.

In this case, you should get advice about whether you should fight the insurer in Court, but there would have been no problem in the first place if you had not switched insurers.

There are good reasons for switching insurers – like lower premiums, and higher benefits, but there can also be bad reasons for switching insurers – like commissions and kickbacks to salespeople and agents.

If you are considering switching from one insurer to another, you should get independent advice (and advice from a bank is not independent), read the fine print about exclusions and waiting periods, and make sure the insurer gets all the details about your medical history.

For more information, see rejected insurance claims.

The contents of this blog post are considered accurate as at the date of publication. However the applicable laws may be subject to change, thereby affecting the accuracy of the article. The information contained in this blog post is of a general nature only and is not specific to anyone’s personal circumstances. Please seek legal advice before acting on any of the information contained in this post.

Thank you for your feedback.

Related blog posts

Superannuation and Insurance
How prepared are you for a financial emergency?

Whilst not all financial surprises are bad – if you won lotto tonight, that’d definitely be classified as a positive! But how prepared are you if a not so pleasant financial surprise happened? The pandemic has taught us that there are times when we simply don’t know what’s going to happen next. But there are steps you can take to try to protect yourself and your family if a sudden financial emergency was to occur. This first one is also probably the most obvious. To prepare for a financial emergency, such as being laid off your job, having your hours at work cut, or if you’re suddenly struck down by an injury or illness – you should have an emergency savings fund at the ready...

Debt stress from a financial emergency
Superannuation and Insurance
Using super to buy a first home

Australia is currently seeing a boom in our property market. The combination of record low interest rates and increased demand has seen house prices dramatically increase in recent months. This has led to a push by some to let Australians dip into their superannuation savings to help them enter the property market sooner (this is different to the current First Home Super Saver Scheme, which allows first home buyers to save money for a first home inside their super fund). At first, the idea seems like a good one. It gives first home buyers the option to use their hard-earned savings to get onto the real estate market earlier than if they had to save for a deposit from scratch. It allows...

House auction sold sign
Superannuation and Insurance
Super stapling - Don’t be left without TPD insurance in your time of need

New super accounts will no longer be created every time a worker changes jobs meaning they will have one single default account that follows them, from 1 July 2021. The “stapling” reform was announced by the Federal Government in 2020, to avoid workers ending up with multiple super funds, paying multiple insurance premiums and account fees, causing their superannuation balance to shrink unnecessarily before retirement. While keeping your balance as high as possible is a positive, the move may come at a cost to some people finding themselves without insurance if they fall ill or become injured after moving to work in a more dangerous industry where their insurance policy does not...

Young mine worker contemplating his superannuation

We're here to help

Start your online claim check now. Or, if you have a question, get in touch with our team.